Workplace Culture

Thanksgiving 2014: Overcooking the Bird

By James Tehrani

Nov. 6, 2014

A modest proposal for retailers this Thanksgiving: Let workers eat dinner — with their families.

Let them eat turkey, let them eat yams, let them eat pumpkin pie.

Let them be.

Ever since the Great Recession, many retailers have been playing a game of one-upsmanship with opening stores on Thanksgiving. Every year it seems to be getting earlier. JCPenney, for instance, just announced it will open its stores at 5 p.m. on Turkey Day this year, possibly to get a jump-start on department stores like Macy’s that plan to open at 6. That not good enough for you? Kmart opens at 6, too — 6 a.m. that is. It’ll also be open for 42 straight hours in case you forgot something the first time around.

Nothing says great customer service like long lines, sales prices that don’t ring up properly and overly tired workers.

With the growing list of stores that will open early on Thanksgiving this year, it’s nice to see some companies taking a stand and saying, “We can wait,” and not opening on Thanksgiving. They seem to have taken Annie’s advice to heart: “I love ya, tomorrow; you’re always a day away.”

In other words, a “door-buster” on Thursday isn’t any better than a “door-buster” on Friday. People will come.

And don’t give me this “customers want to start shopping at 5 p.m. or 6 p.m. on Thanksgiving” nonsense. Customers have the Internet to buy stuff whenever they like. Consumers also went decades without shopping on Thanksgiving, and they liked it — or at least lived with it. That’s why Black Friday became such a big deal for shopping.

Craig Johnson, president of the consulting firm Custom Growth Partners, said it best when he told Time: “There is a law of diminishing returns,” he said: “Stores that open on Thanksgiving ‘risk cannibalizing’ sales that they would have made at another time.”

Workers deserve the chance to eat with their families just like anyone else. Thanksgiving dinner at 1:30 to get to work by 4 to open by 5? Bah humbug to that.

Here’s hoping retailers start realizing Thanksgiving sales aren’t about “gravy” as much as they are about overcooking the bird.

James Tehrani is the director of content strategy at FlexJobs.

Schedule, engage, and pay your staff in one system with


Join over 52,000 of your HR peers

Don't miss out on the latest tactics and insights at the forefront of HR.