Scheduling
Time & Attendance
Forecasting
Employee App
Payroll Integrations
Communications
Workplace Culture
By Tim Garrett
Mar. 18, 2015
Photo courtesy of Thinkstock.
Like many incidents that cause sorrow and suffering in a workplace, nothing seemed out of the ordinary at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston on a fateful day in January.
According to an account in The Boston Globe, a 55-year-old man, Stephen Pasceri, drove to the hospital that morning to confront a cardiologist who had operated on the man’s mother a few months earlier; she died a month later. The man was insistent on seeing the cardiologist, but did not appear visibly enraged or upset, according to reports. However, police said the man later shot the cardiologist dead in an exam room before killing himself.
Savvy employers are losing sleep as workplace violence becomes a more pressing concern. Employers see the growing trends:
In the midst of these concerns, employers have a duty to provide a safe workplace. While the concerns are not new, they appear to be on the rise. Within the past year, shootings at three different hospitals and an accidental shooting resulting in the death of a Wal-Mart shopper highlight the heightened visibility. Domestic violence and racial or religious tensions have spilled over into the workplace, which arguably increase an employer’s duty to foresee these concerns and be prepared. Note the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s recent guidance on domestic violence.
Health care workers in particular seem especially vulnerable, but the concerns arise also in traditional plant settings, said Jill Bond, vice president and general counsel at Rich Products Corp., a Buffalo, New York-based frozen-food company.
“We must plan for many potential situations,” Bond said. “We must be proactive in dealing with employees who appear to have challenges in getting along with others, especially in certain domestic situations, and we might refer someone to our employee assistance program, for example.
“I believe it is difficult for employers to find the right balance between ‘off-duty’ conduct and what implicates ‘on-duty’ responsibilities for an employer, especially in light of new EEOC guidelines,” she added. “This is especially true when co-workers are also companions or relatives outside the workplace. On the one hand, we have to be careful about being too intrusive. On the other hand, we don’t want to look back after a violent incident and wonder whether we could have done more.”
What’s an Employer to Do?
The duty to provide a safe workplace arises from a U.S. employer’s obligations under the Occupational Safety and Health Act as well as its common-law duty to act reasonably in eliminating or reducing risk of injury to its employees or patrons. The shield of workers’ compensation laws reduces some of an employer’s liability risk arising from the common law duty, but that shield is under increasing attack. And, more importantly, no employer wants a tragic shooting or serious injury on its premises, even if the financial repercussions may be limited.
So, what are reasonable, proactive steps an employer should consider?
Employers should consider banning weapons on premises. This policy will highlight the gun-debate tension mentioned above. While some jurisdictions may not allow an outright ban, even in those areas, the employer should write a policy to ensure that only persons who have taken training and obtained permits are allowed to carry weapons. In those jurisdictions that allow persons to carry guns with permits, the employer should consider requiring workers to notify the employer. If the employer is in a high-risk area or industry, the employer should have a security force and, more importantly, one with appropriate training.
Beyond banning weapons or requiring workers to notify the company if they bring a gun to work, employers should consider surveillance cameras, especially at entrance areas, and should publicize their presence. Publicized surveillance can have a significant deterrent effect, and publicizing their presence also remedies any privacy concerns of employees and patrons.
Additionally, an employer’s policy relating to workplace violence and/or threats should include a “zero tolerance” statement for such instances, particularly in today’s climate of rising concerns. Of course, “zero tolerance” still requires some level of judgment and does not mandate a termination for any and all offenses, but the policy should be direct, clear and forceful. And an employer’s actions in responding to an alleged threat should be consistent with its expressed concern.
Compared with other companies, health care employers often have heightened issues because of the impaired nature of some of their “customers” — the patients.
“We strive to treat our patients in the most caring and compassionate manner to ensure effective dialysis treatments in a safe and comfortable environment,” said Jessica Emler, public information coordinator at Nashville, Tennessee-based Dialysis Clinic Inc. “However, we understand that no health care setting is truly immune to disruptive behavior. Inappropriate behavior, most often in the form of abusive, harassing or profane language, can occur at any time. Therefore, we have open and honest conversations at local and corporate meetings about addressing inappropriate behavior early and effectively in an attempt to provide a pleasant and comfortable dialysis facility.”
Bad behavior is more of an outlier at the clinic than the norm, Emler said. But should the need arise, she said the clinic’s human resources, risk management and legal teams are all available to support staff on finding ways to improve and continue the relationship with a disruptive patient.
“Of the more than 14,000 patients we serve, we have witnessed very few bad patients. More often, it is poor decision-making by the patient who is upset about his/her circumstances or long-term prognosis,” Emler said. “In the dialysis facility, inappropriate/disruptive language accounts for 90 percent of the patient-related behavior issues that we address. When a patient says something inappropriate, we first request that staff hold an interdisciplinary team meeting with the patient to see if we can identify the root cause to the patient’s outburst and show our resolve that we do not tolerate unacceptable behavior in our clinic.”
The employer’s policy relating to workplace violence and/or threats of such violence should contemplate domestic violence issues. In the past few years, the EEOC has indicated that it intends to focus on domestic violence issues. On Oct. 12, 2012, the EEOC published a guidance fact sheet advising employers to be careful not to “overlook” domestic violence as a potential basis for employment and disability discrimination, workplace harassment or retaliation. As Michael Baldonado, district director for the EEOC’s San Francisco office has stated, Employers should take time to “learn how to respond to domestic violence when it impacts their workplace.” Employers should consider the following:
No amount of preparation can ensure that a workplace remains free of violence. But HR professionals who enact a deliberate plan in pursuit of a company’s duty to provide a safe workplace can minimize the risks and, when an incident occurs, be well placed to mitigate the damage. And, just maybe, they can rest a little easier at night.
Tim K. Garrett is a member in the Labor & Employment practice at the law firm Bass, Berry & Sims in Nashville, Tennessee. Comment below or email editors@workforce.com. Follow Workforce on Twitter at @workforcenews.
Come see what we’re building in the world of predictive employee scheduling, superior labor insights and next-gen employee apps. We’re on a mission to automate workforce management for hourly employees and bring productivity, optimization and engagement to the frontline.
Workplace Culture
Workplace productivity statistics and trends you need to knowSummary There was a 2.4% decrease in productivity in Q2 2022 – the largest decline since the U.S. Burea...
productivity, statistics, trends, workplace
Workplace Culture
5 lunch break statistics that shed light on American work cultureSummary Research shows how taking lunch breaks enhances employee engagement and productivity. Despite t...
lunch breaks, scheduling, statistics
Workplace Culture
6 Things Leadership can do to Prevent Nurse BurnoutSummary Nurse burnout is a serious issue in the healthcare business and has several negative consequenc...
burnout, Healthcare, hospitals, nurses