Commentary & Opinion

Hospital employees are about to lose a vaccination lawsuit against their employer in spectacular fashion

Jon Hyman

02 June 2021

Some 117 employees have sued their employer, Houston Methodist Hospital, over its requirement that all employees receive the COVID-19 vaccine.

According to ABC News, the hospital gave its employees a June 7 deadline to get vaccinated or face suspension and termination. The employees allege that their employer is “illegally requiring its employees to be injected with an experimental vaccine as a condition of employment.” The lawsuit adds that the hospital’s vaccine requirement violates the “Nuremberg Code and the public policy of the state of Texas.”

In a statement, hospital CEO Dr. Marc Boom said, “It is unfortunate that the few remaining employees who refuse to get vaccinated and put our patients first are responding in this way. It is legal for health care institutions to mandate vaccines, as we have done with the flu vaccine since 2009. The COVID-19 vaccines have proven through rigorous trials to be very safe and very effective and are not experimental.”

Dr. Boom is 100 percent correct; the hospital’s policy is legal. Here’s why, and why this lawsuit will fail spectacularly.
1. The EEOC expressly says that mandatory vaccine policies are 100 percent legal (as long as an employer makes allowances to accommodate employees whose underlying disabilities, sincerely held religious beliefs, practices, or observances, or pregnancy prevents them from getting vaccinated). Because I’ve seen zero references that any of the 117 plaintiffs are claiming an ADA or Title VII violation, I conclude that the hospital has met its legal obligations in this regard. (Note, however, that Texas is considering pending legislation that would make “COVID-19 vaccination status” a protected class under its employment discrimination law.)
2. Public policy actually favors as many individuals getting vaccinated as possible. Just ask the Biden White House, the CDC, the EEOCOSHA, just about any other government agency, and even the State of Texas (although its governor did sign an Executive Order prohibiting government entities from compelling that anyone receives a COVID-19 vaccine administered under an emergency use authorization). Note also that there are efforts underway in states across the country (e.g.Ohio) to prohibit a business from mandating vaccines or permitting individuals to decline a required vaccine based on medical contraindications, natural immunity, or reasons of conscience.
3. The Nuremberg Code is not a thing, at least not in this context. In fact, there’s been a lot of chatting lately about the Nuremberg Code as a justification to refuse vaccine mandates. It’s wrong and it’s offensive. It’s a set of research ethics principles for human experimentation created as a result of the Nuremberg trials at the end of World War II. It was a reaction to the medical atrocities committed by Dr. Josef Mengele and other Nazis during the war, with the intent of protecting people from suffering similar atrocities. To compare Nazi war crimes to a life-saving vaccine that has been tested and vetted is the height of disgusting selfishness.
Bottom line: If you want to mandate that your employees get vaccinated as a condition of employment, you are legally in the clear to do so, subject to reasonable accommodation exceptions under the ADA for disabled employees, and under Title VII for employees’ sincerely held religious beliefs, practices, or observances, and for pregnant employees. Any other gripes, complaints, or objections by employees are just smokescreens that you can legally ignore, at least for now.

Written by Jon Hyman

About Workforce.com

blog workforce

We build robust scheduling & attendance software for businesses with 500+ frontline workers. With custom BI reporting and demand-driven scheduling, we help our customers reduce labor spend and increase profitability across their business. It's as simple as that.

Book a call
See the software
workforce news

Relevant Videos

This is Workforce.com

Hi, My name is Meg and this is my introduction to Workforce.com

Case Study: COVIDCheck Colorado

Find out how Workforce.com powered vaccine sites with demand driven scheduling and attendance.

Related Articles

workforce blog

Compliance

The 10-minute guide to 2021 labor law compliance

Labor laws are a potentially lethal minefield for companies, particularly in today’s turbulent labor ma...

compliance, HR, HR technology, human resources, labor law compliance

workforce blog

Commentary & Opinion

Workplace things COVID has not changed: You can still fire dishonest employees

Suppose an employee leaves work claiming COVID-like symptoms. He then calls off work for the next two w...

COVID-19, FFCRA, human resources, termination

workforce blog

Legal

Q&A: Excelling in defense of employers sued for wage and hour violations

Wage and hour violations among the familiar labor law challenges facing Annette A. Idalski as she ‘stri...

compliance, Department of Labor, wage and hour

Read the Workforce.com magazine

workforce magazine