Economy May Be Bottoming, but 401(k) Matches Won’t Be Back Soon

By Staff Report

Aug. 12, 2009

Despite recent reports that the economy may have bottomed out, it will be several more months before employers reinstate their defined-contribution plan matches, experts say.

Since November, 8 percent of the Fortune 500 companies have suspended or reduced their matches, according to Hewitt Associates.

However, a June Watson Wyatt Worldwide survey finds that 42 percent of employers plan to bring back their match in the next 12 months.

But most employers probably won’t reinstate their matches until late 2010 or early 2011, experts say.

“My prediction is January 1, 2011,” said Michael Weddell, a principal and senior defined-contribution consultant in Mercer’s retirement, risk and finance consulting business.

Weddell says he’s date-specific because many employers have 401(k) plans with a safe harbor plan design, meaning they run on a calendar year and have to announce in November any changes they are making to the plans.

“January 1, 2010, is too soon to make changes because the recession is still going on,” he said. “So I think January 1, 2011, is when you will see some announcements.”

There is no pressure on employers to rush to bring their 401(k) matches back, Weddell said.

“The price companies pay for reducing or suspending their matches is increased turnover,” he said. “But the job market is such right now that people aren’t leaving.”

Many employers have started talking about reinstating their 401(k) matches, but are looking closely at whether they will bring them back at the same levels, said Rob Reiskytl, leader of Hewitt’s defined-contribution consulting practice.

“We are working with some organizations that aren’t just looking at the timing of when to reinstate, but also of exactly what to reinstate,” he said.

Some companies that previously offered non-matching contributions to employees may no longer do so, he said.

Also, many employers are discussing changing their matches from a fixed portion of salary to discretionary matches based on company performance, experts say.

“This is a hot topic of discussion,” Reiskytl said.

Starbucks announced in December that it was moving from a fixed defined-contribution match to a profit-sharing feature. In late July, the company said it would match U.S. employees’ contributions to it 401(k) plan for 2009, which ends September 27.

“I think many companies may be looking at this,” said Lenny Sanicola, practice leader of benefits for Scottsdale, Arizona-based WorldatWork, a global human resources association focused on compensation and benefits. “They are looking at whether their matches were overly generous to begin with.”

Many employers may opt to bring back their defined-contribution plan matches incrementally, Weddell said. “I would guess that some companies will raise it to an intermediate level, then maybe in another year after that go to the previous level,” he said.

And then some employers, particularly in battered industries such as automotive suppliers, may not bring their defined-contribution matches back at all, said Jack Abraham, a principal in PricewaterhouseCoopers’ HR services group.

“There is no guarantee,” he said. “I don’t think in my 20 years in this industry that we have ever seen anything this bad.”

—Jessica Marquez

Stay informed and connected. Get human resources news and HR features via Workforce Management’s Twitter feed or RSS feeds for mobile devices and news readers.

Schedule, engage, and pay your staff in one system with