Workforce Blogs
Home
Complete archive of features and news articles, sample policies and procedures, assessments, and surveys.
Network and exchange ideas with other members in the forums or ask an expert in one of the hosted forums.
Access vendor directories, product case studies and showcases.
Read Best in Shows, view our conference calendar, read commentaries and take our news poll.
The Hot List
Blogs
Topic Channels
Comp, Benefits, Rewards
HR Management
Legal Insight
Recruiting and Staffing
Software and Technology
Training and Development
= Member Only
Workforce HR Jobs
Find A Job
Post A Job



Subscribe Now
Workforce Magazine
Subscriber Help
























= Member Only


Blog: The Business of Management
 

November 21st, 2007

’Tis the Season for Stupid Job-Hunting Tips

This morning my e-mail contained a well-meaning press release from a recruiting Web site touting “several tips to help find a job during the holidays.”

Sounds like a good idea, no?

Well the problem is that the “tips to help find a job” weren’t really focused on actually landing a job during the holidays, but rather, suggestions to keep job seekers engaged in the job-finding process during the Thanksgiving and Christmas season.

 The “tips,” which were focused entirely toward job seekers and not on hiring managers, included things like:

• “After Thanksgiving, Give Thanks. Send an e-mail or holiday card to those people who have helped with your job search.”
• “Invest in Yourself. Take a professional development class. Check out blogs your friend or colleagues have mentioned. Learn some new industry buzzwords.”
• “Spread the Love. Get involved in volunteering and you may meet people who will make great contacts for a future job.”
•  “Take Advantage of Holiday Parties” to network and let people know you’re still job hunting.
This is all fine advice, albeit somewhat insipid and overly generic, for keeping your mind on the goal of new job. But if you’re one of today’s job seekers, it is unlikely these “tips” will help you find that new position right now.

The reason for this is simple: Very little real hiring goes on between mid-November and mid-January. Yes, there are always exceptions,  like the desperate art director character played by Dustin Hoffman in Kramer vs. Kramer, but my longtime experience as both a hiring manager and a job seeker is that nothing related to job-seeking (and, for that matter, little related to jobs in general) happens from Thanksgiving to about Martin Luther King Jr. Day.

You know all the reasons—you’re living them right now. People are shopping, stressing out about shopping and using up vacation days, in the case of those companies in the use-it-or-lose-it states. Recruiters and hiring managers are in and out of the office. It’s the end of the budget year, and probably most important, no one is in the frame of mind necessary for either end of the hiring process. There’s no serious recruiting or hiring happening until after New Year’s.

My advice is to take a break and recharge your batteries during the holidays so that you’ll be ready to hire or be hired when the real action begins again in mid-January. You’ll be rested, relaxed and well past silly holiday hiring tips that might make somebody feel good, but do nothing to help get good people into jobs.


TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://workforce.com/wpmu/bizmgmt/2007/11/21/holiday_recruiting/trackback/



Comments

I’m amazed at the number of correspondents that think an employee has any right to privacy for emails sent from an office, whether or not the employee was “on the clock.” Pure and simple, the company has a fiduciary obligation to ensure that intellectual capital, trade secrets and other information that might be useful to the competition are kept private within the company.
I am certain that Boeing, like all federal government contractors who participate in the defense industry, has an extensive orientation program wherein an employee is given written “requirements of employment”. Typically, these documents include statements (that are acknowledged by the employee in writing) that the employee has no “right of privacy” in any aspect of the business, and that email and telephone calls will be monitored as will be computer records. Another typical document the employee completes is acknowledgement that if the employee violates the requirements of employment, he/she will be dismissed.
As pointed out earlier, we don’t have the facts, and the “news story” was really more of an editorial against “big business” and “big government”. Did the company security force go too far in following the employee off the business campus and monitoring the employee’s contacts? Not at all if the employee held a federal security clearance and worked on defense industry projects. Despite what some extremists might think, the federal government has a concrete legal responsibility to ensure that “hostile foreign powers or terrorists” don’t get information that would compromise national security or national defense.
I realize that many of my colleagues in HR are very liberal in their feelings, but please put some common sense into your thinking! If the employee was unwilling to fulfill the requirements of employment, he should have taken a different position with a different employer. Acceptance of employment is tacit approval that the employee will comply with work rules.

I was called for an interivew the week before Thanksgiving and hired December 3rd. this may be an exception, but the company I work for is actively recruiting right now, and we hire up to 100 people per week…so I think your advice may be a bit off.

I think the suggestions made about continuing to network and writing notes of thanks make a lot of sense for a job seeker. Just because fewer hires may happen during the holiday season doesn’t mean that one shouldn’t continue to network during this time so that when the requisition opens in January, the hiring manager can think of that person or be referred to that person. Additionally, while things do slow down, they don’t always come to a halt. If a person is serious about finding new work, then they will continue to sieze these opportunities to network and sowe the seeds to harvest later. If I were unemployed right now, I would have found your article discouraging.

I’d bet the reason for this press release was that job search traffic plummets through the holiday season. Companies like the one that e-mailed you need to do anything to keep up traffic to their sites. They’re desperate.
I wrote a post about the trends in job search traffic on my blog and it can be found at
http://www.onedayonejob.com/blog/end-of-year-job-search/

Depending on where you are also has an affect on the job market. I live in a predominately tourist area. I try to help folks get back to work for a living as well as help employers find the right matches and I do notice an increase in restaurant and hotel jobs. Unfortunately, these ’seasonal jobs’ are for low pay, which poses a challenge to my veteran military customers. I agree with a previous poster, the labor does slow down but it doesn’t come to a halt. For the average job seeker that could mean the chances of finding that ‘right job’ becomes much lower since the jobs do slow down but the number of un-employed folks remains the same. Don’t give up on your job search. But beware not to allow yourself to become desperate and take the first thing that comes along.

I am HR Director for a company of 400+ employees. We are hiring right now and not for temporary or seasonal jobs.
If I were looking for work now, I wouldn’t take a break during the holidays. Even if little hiring is being done, there are lots of other job seekers that will take a break. That means less competition for the jobs that are out there. Use that as motivation to recharge your batteries.
Many of us do not have the luxury of having a job that will allow us to do nothing between Thanksgiving and Martin Luther’s Birthday. In fact, I don’t know many employers that would be happy knowing HR is taking a couple of months off during the year.

I have been involved with outplacement for the past ten years. Our data reveals that interviewing and hiring does occur during the last and first quarters. Because there is a perception that hiring does not occur during fourth quarter and soome job seekers do take timeoff during the holidays, competitively speaking this is a great time of year to explore opportunities in the marketplace.

I have to disagree with you. Many companies still do hire during the holiday season, and I think people who are looking for jobs should continue to seek employment during this time. I interviewed for my current position in November and started on December 10th. I’m glad I didn’t take your advice!!!


Post a comment

This is a captcha-picture. It is used to prevent mass-access by robots. (see: www.captcha.net)

You must read and type the 5 chars within 0..9 and A..F, and submit the form.

  

Please, generate a





Blog Index







Recent Posts

Blog Archives

Categories



Recent Comments

Other Workforce Blogs

Blog Roll







Copyright © 1995-2007 Crain Communications Inc.
All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use Privacy Statement